Charter

Aircraft Management Agreements and How Lenders View Them

By the JetFinex editorial team
How we research and review
Published
Updated , 8 min read
The short answer

Lenders view an aircraft management agreement as a change in who operates their collateral, so most want to approve it before you sign. They look at who holds operational control, whether the flying is private (Part 91) or charter (Part 135), whether the operator is properly certificated, and whether insurance names the lender. Disclose the arrangement before closing, because lenders often limit charter use by hours or percentage, and operations that differ from what you told the lender can create a covenant problem.

Key takeaways

  • Tell the lender about any management or charter arrangement before closing; AOPA Finance says an intention to fly Part 135 charter almost always affects a lender's decision.
  • Operational control decides which rules apply to each flight, and lenders read the agreement to see who really holds it.
  • Many lenders allow limited Part 135 use, capped by hours or a share of annual flying, and some will not finance charter-only operations.
  • Insurance must fit both the management agreement and the lender's requirements, including coverage for the owner's own flights.
  • Get lender consent in writing and keep the management agreement subordinate to the lender's rights.

How do lenders view an aircraft management agreement?

A lender sees a management agreement as a change in who operates its collateral. The aircraft and the loan stay the same, but a third party may now fly, maintain, insure and schedule the aircraft. Because that affects the aircraft's value and the borrower's ability to repay, lenders usually want to review and approve the agreement before it takes effect.

The National Aircraft Finance Association (NAFA) tells lenders to document the intended operations in the loan agreement and monitor compliance over the life of the loan. That is why your loan documents probably contain a use covenant, an operator covenant, or both. If you plan to hire a management company, read those clauses first.

This guide is for owners and operators who finance or lease aircraft and are considering a management company. For the wider picture of how lenders underwrite charter operations, see our guide to financing a Part 135 charter aircraft and the airplane financing overview.

What is operational control, and why does it decide everything?

Operational control is the authority over initiating, conducting or terminating a flight, as defined in 14 CFR 1.1. Whoever holds it is responsible for the flight, and the type of operation that results (private under Part 91, or commercial under Part 135) follows from it.

Most management structures fall into one of three patterns:

  • Owner-operated with a manager's support. The owner keeps operational control and flies under Part 91. The manager supplies services such as crew, scheduling, maintenance tracking and hangarage.
  • Charter management. The aircraft is added to a Part 135 certificate holder's fleet. For charter flights, the certificate holder holds operational control, and the aircraft is covered by Part 135, which 14 CFR 135.1 applies to on-demand commuter and air taxi operations.
  • Mixed use. The owner flies under Part 91 and third-party charters run under the certificate holder's Part 135 authority. The agreement must be clear about which flights fall under which regime.

NAFA notes that the FAA assesses operational control using factors in Advisory Circular 91-37B, such as who assigns crew, fuels the aircraft, initiates flights, hires pilots, and maintains and insures the aircraft. It also warns that a dry lease can be recharacterized as a wet lease, particularly when the same pilots are shared across multiple leases. A lender reading your agreement is asking the same question the FAA would: who is actually in control?

How do lenders treat Part 91 versus Part 135 use?

Lenders often treat private use and charter use differently, and many write the permitted use into the security agreement. AvBuyer quotes a NAFA spokesperson saying "We often see the security agreement specifically define the particular utilization permitted."

The same article reports a range of lender positions:

  • Adam Meredith of AOPA Finance said an intention to use the aircraft for Part 135 charter almost always affects a lender's decision, so it should be disclosed up front.
  • Many lenders allow limited Part 135 use, capped by hours or by a percentage of annual use.
  • Luci Johnson of PNC Aviation Finance said PNC does not finance third-party charter-only operations, and adds restrictions on charter use and total hours. She said some PNC clients fly all Part 135 hours but only for owners and related parties, and that "it's the intent we're underwriting, not the actual technical classification."

The practical lesson: a lender's answer depends on its own policy. Do not assume a charter-management placement is allowed because an earlier loan or a friend's loan allowed it.

What do lenders check in the agreement and the operator?

Expect a lender to review the operator and the contract. Based on the NAFA guidance, typical checks include:

  • Operator certification. For Part 135 use, the lender validates the operator's certificate and operations specifications. NAFA adds that Part 135 operators also need DOT registration under Part 298, and that charter brokers must register under DOT Part 295.
  • Permitted operations. The contract should define permitted operations and keep compensation within FAA rules.
  • Leases and truth in leasing. If the arrangement includes a lease, 14 CFR 91.23 sets out the required truth-in-leasing clause and filing steps. NAFA says leases on aircraft over 12,500 pounds MTOW must satisfy it. Have counsel confirm whether it applies to your aircraft.
  • Lender protections. NAFA lists recording the lease and collateral assignment with the FAA, powers of attorney to terminate leases on default, and standstill provisions as tools lenders consider.
  • Maintenance. AvBuyer reports lenders may require enrollment in an engine maintenance program and review maintenance tracking reports. A manager that tracks maintenance well helps; one that does not hurts.

How should insurance work with a management agreement?

Insurance has to satisfy three parties at once: the manager, the owner and the lender. NAFA says insurance coverage can be voided by non-compliant operations, so lenders verify coverage at closing and monitor it afterward. Part 135 operators must also file insurance documentation with the DOT.

For an owner, the key point is that being listed on a manager's policy is not automatically the same as being covered for your own flying. Confirm in writing that the endorsements cover you and any affiliates that operate the aircraft, name the lender as loss payee and additional insured as the loan documents require, and match the limits the lender set. Our guide to lender insurance requirements explains loss payee, additional insured and breach of warranty terms in more detail.

What should you settle before you sign a management agreement?

Use this checklist before you sign, and share the draft with your lender.

  1. Read the use, operator and lease covenants in your loan or lease documents.
  2. Ask the lender in writing whether the arrangement is permitted, and on what terms (hour caps, percentage caps, approved operators).
  3. Decide who holds operational control for each type of flight and write it into the agreement.
  4. Confirm the operator's certificate, operations specifications and DOT registrations if charter is involved.
  5. Make the management agreement subordinate to the lender's rights, and ask whether the lender wants a consent or acknowledgment signed by the manager.
  6. Settle insurance: who insures, who is covered, who is loss payee, and what happens on cancellation.
  7. Define fees, maintenance responsibilities, records access and termination rights, including what happens if the loan defaults.
  8. Have aviation counsel and a tax advisor review the arrangement. Tax treatment of charter use depends on facts and changes by state and over time; this article gives no tax advice.

What does the lender's review mean in dollars? (hypothetical)

The numbers below are hypothetical and only show how a charter-hours cap can interact with a plan. They are not from any lender's policy.

Planned annual flying (hypothetical)400 hours
Hypothetical lender cap on Part 135 use25% of annual hours
Maximum charter hours under the cap400 x 0.25 = 100 hours
Charter hours in the owner's business plan160 hours
Hours over the cap160 - 100 = 60 hours

In this hypothetical, the plan exceeds the cap by 60 hours. The owner would need to ask the lender for a higher cap, reduce charter flying, or choose a lender that accepts the plan. Try your own numbers in the charter breakeven calculator and test the loan side with the aircraft loan calculator.

What if the lender says no?

You have a few options. Negotiate a hours or percentage cap instead of a ban. Ask whether the lender will approve a specific operator it already knows. Consider whether a lease structure fits better; see operating leases and finance leases, although AvBuyer reports leases are usually more restrictive than loans because of return conditions. Or choose a lender whose policy matches your plan before you buy, not after.

Whatever you choose, the safest approach is early disclosure. AvBuyer quotes Johnson saying operations that differ from original representations can create problems and added expense. If you are building a deal file that shows lenders your intended operations from day one, JetFinex can help you organize it.

Charter Aircraft Breakeven Calculator

Charter hours a year to cover fixed costs.

Open the tool

Want the payment on a specific aircraft? Try the aircraft loan calculator: set the price, down payment, rate, term and balloon and see the monthly payment and total interest.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need my lender's permission to put my aircraft under a management agreement?

Usually yes. Most loan and lease documents restrict how the aircraft is operated and by whom, so a management or charter arrangement typically needs written consent. Check the use and operator covenants in your documents and ask before you sign.

Can I put a financed aircraft on a Part 135 certificate?

Sometimes. Many lenders allow limited Part 135 use capped by hours or a percentage of annual use, while some, such as PNC according to AvBuyer, do not finance third-party charter-only operations. Ask the lender early.

What is operational control?

14 CFR 1.1 defines operational control as the exercise of authority over initiating, conducting or terminating a flight. It determines who is responsible for the flight and which operating rules apply.

Why do lenders care about insurance in a management agreement?

Non-compliant operations can void coverage, according to the National Aircraft Finance Association. Lenders therefore check the policies and endorsements that protect their interest and watch them after closing.

Does a management agreement change who owns the aircraft?

No. The owner stays the registered owner and the lender's collateral does not change. What changes is who operates, maintains and insures the aircraft day to day, which is why lenders review the agreement.

Sources

This guide is educational and is not tax, legal or investment advice. See our editorial standards and disclosures. Spot an error? Tell us.