Tax

Tax Considerations in an Aircraft Sale-Leaseback

By the JetFinex editorial team
How we research and review
Published
Updated , 8 min read
The short answer

In an aircraft sale-leaseback, the sale is a taxable disposition: gain up to the depreciation you took is ordinary income under Section 1245, even though the aircraft never leaves your operation. If the lease is a true lease, you can then deduct the rent as a business expense. If the lease looks like financing, for example with a nominal buyout, the IRS can treat the deal as a loan instead.

Key takeaways

  • Selling the aircraft to the lessor is a taxable sale, and gain up to prior depreciation is ordinary income under Section 1245.
  • A fully depreciated aircraft can produce a tax bill larger than the cash left after the loan payoff.
  • Rent is deductible only if the lease is a true lease; IRS Publication 334 says you cannot deduct rent if you have or will receive equity in or title to the property.
  • A buyout below fair market value is the clearest sign a deal may be treated as financing rather than a sale and lease.
  • Selling to a related lessor can make a loss nondeductible and turn gain into ordinary income.

Is an aircraft sale-leaseback taxable?

Yes, in most cases. Selling the aircraft to the lessor is a taxable sale even though the aircraft stays on your ramp the same day. IRS Publication 544 says you figure gain by subtracting your adjusted basis from your amount realized. Adjusted basis is roughly what you paid, plus improvements, minus the depreciation you claimed.

On a business aircraft, most of that gain is usually ordinary income. Section 1245 treats gain on depreciable personal property as ordinary income up to the depreciation allowed or allowable. Only gain above that amount can be Section 1231 gain, which may qualify for capital gain treatment. Because aircraft rarely sell for more than they cost, the whole gain on a depreciated aircraft is often recapture, reported on Form 4797.

There is no way to roll the gain into the lease. Since 2018, Section 1031 covers only real property, so an aircraft sale cannot be deferred as a like-kind exchange. Our guide to like-kind exchanges and aircraft after 2018 explains the change. If you are new to the structure itself, start with how aircraft sale-leasebacks work, then come back to the tax side.

Why can the tax exceed the cash you receive?

Because gain is figured on the sale price, not on the cash you keep. Publication 544 says the amount realized includes liabilities the buyer assumes or that the property is subject to. When the lessor pays off your loan at closing, that payoff is part of your amount realized, but none of it reaches your bank account.

This hits hardest when the aircraft was fully expensed with bonus depreciation or Section 179. Its basis may be close to zero, so nearly the entire sale price is ordinary income, while the cash released is only the price minus the loan. Run the numbers before you sign a letter of intent, not after.

What does the tax look like on a real-sized deal?

The figures below are hypothetical and simplified. A charter company bought a turboprop for $3,000,000 and fully expensed it, so its adjusted basis is $0. It still owes $1,500,000. A lessor agrees to buy the aircraft for $2,400,000 and lease it back for a hypothetical $30,000 a month. The example uses the 21% federal corporate rate and ignores state tax, fees and the timing of estimated payments.

Sale price to lessor (hypothetical)$2,400,000
Adjusted basis after full expensing$0
Gain, all Section 1245 ordinary income$2,400,000
Loan payoff at closing$1,500,000
Cash released before tax$900,000
Federal tax on the gain at 21%$504,000
Cash released after federal tax$396,000
Annual rent, deductible if a true lease ($30,000 x 12)$360,000

The sale looks like it frees $900,000, but more than half of it goes to federal tax in the year of sale. The rent deductions give some of that back over the lease term, but slowly. A company with losses or carryforwards to absorb the gain sees a very different result than one already paying tax, which is why the same deal can be smart for one operator and costly for another. Model the lease side in the sale-leaseback calculator and compare it with refinancing the existing loan in the aircraft loan calculator.

When does the IRS treat a sale-leaseback as a loan instead?

When the lessor does not really own the aircraft. Tax treatment follows substance, not labels. In Frank Lyon Co. v. United States, the Supreme Court held that the form of a sale-leaseback governs for tax purposes so long as the lessor retains significant and genuine attributes of the traditional lessor status, and said a sale-leaseback in and of itself does not deny the deductions.

The IRS's best-known checklist is Rev. Proc. 2001-28. It sets guidelines the IRS uses only for advance rulings on leveraged leases, not audit rules, but practitioners use it as a benchmark. Among them:

  • Lessor at risk. The lessor must have an unconditional at-risk investment of at least 20 percent of the property's cost, maintained through the lease term.
  • Real residual. At least 20 percent of original cost must be a reasonable estimate of fair market value at lease end, with a remaining useful life of the longer of one year or 20 percent of the original estimate.
  • No cheap buyout. No member of the lessee group may have a right to buy the property for less than its fair market value when the right is exercised.
  • No lessee funding. The lessee generally may not pay for the cost of the property, with limited exceptions for certain improvements.

If the deal fails these tests, the IRS can recast it. Rev. Proc. 2001-28 points to Rev. Rul. 55-540, which lists conditions that suggest a conditional sale rather than a lease. The table compares the two outcomes in general terms.

QuestionRespected as sale and true leaseRecast as financing
Is gain recognized at closing?Yes, on the sale to the lessorGenerally no, because no sale is treated as occurring
Who depreciates the aircraft?The lessorThe operator keeps depreciating its existing basis
What does the operator deduct?Rent, under Section 162Interest on the deemed loan, not rent
Typical purchase optionFair market valueNominal or well below expected value

The buyout is the easiest place to see the line. IRS Publication 334 says that if you have or will receive equity in or title to the property, you cannot deduct the rent. Our guide to fair market value vs one-dollar buyout leases covers the commercial trade-off, and the aircraft finance lease page explains how ownership-style leases are structured.

How is the rent deducted after the sale?

Under a true lease, rent for an aircraft used in your trade or business is generally deductible under Section 162. Three rules shape how much and when.

  • Uneven rent. Section 467 can require rent to be accrued on a set schedule when a lease has deferred or prepaid rent. It does not apply to agreements where total payments do not exceed $250,000, so smaller leases fall outside it. Step-up or skip-payment schedules deserve a review.
  • Business use. A business aircraft is listed property. Publication 946 says a lessee of leased listed property other than a passenger automobile must add an inclusion amount to income in the first year qualified business use is 50% or less. See our guide to business use percentage and aircraft depreciation.
  • Personal and entertainment use. The entertainment-use rules in 26 CFR 1.274-10 apply to any aircraft owned by, leased to or chartered to the taxpayer, and the expenses they cover include all costs paid or incurred for aircraft leased to the taxpayer. Moving from owning to leasing does not escape them, so keep flight logs as carefully after the sale as before.

Selling to your own leasing company or a company you control changes the math in two ways. First, Section 267 disallows losses on sales between related persons, such as an individual and a corporation in which they own more than 50 percent in value of the stock. Publication 544 explains the related-person rules. Second, Publication 544 says gain on the sale of property that is depreciable in the buyer's hands is ordinary income when the sale is between certain related parties.

A sale to an unrelated lessor at a loss is different. A net Section 1231 loss is ordinary, according to Publication 544, so an aircraft sold for less than its basis can produce a deductible loss. Related-party leases also draw state sales tax scrutiny, covered next.

What should you check before you sign?

Sales and use tax comes first. Barnes & Thornburg describes how many states let a lessor buy an aircraft without tax as a purchase for resale and collect tax on the rent instead, with conditions such as a sales tax license before closing and timely remittance of tax on rent. Our guide to sales and use tax on aircraft purchases compares states. Then work through this list with your tax advisor:

  1. Confirm the aircraft's adjusted basis and total depreciation, so you know the recapture.
  2. Compare the gain with the cash you will net after the loan payoff and any prepayment penalty.
  3. Check whether losses, carryforwards or a same-year aircraft purchase could absorb the gain.
  4. Read the purchase option. A fair market value option supports true lease treatment; a nominal one points toward financing.
  5. Review rent steps and deferrals for Section 467, and confirm business use will stay above 50%.
  6. Flag any relationship between you and the lessor.
  7. Confirm the sales and use tax treatment of both the sale and the rent in each state involved.

The sale-leaseback structure page and the aircraft leasing hub show how this deal compares with refinancing and other options, and the airplane financing guide covers the loan route. This article explains general federal rules and is not tax advice. Confirm your facts with a tax advisor or aviation counsel before you sign. When you are ready to compare a sale-leaseback with a refinance on real quotes, JetFinex can help you start a deal file.

Aircraft Sale-Leaseback Calculator

Cash released and the monthly lease that follows.

Open the tool

Want the payment on a specific aircraft? Try the aircraft loan calculator: set the price, down payment, rate, term and balloon and see the monthly payment and total interest.

Frequently asked questions

Is an aircraft sale-leaseback taxable?

Usually, yes. The sale to the lessor is a disposition, and gain is figured by subtracting your adjusted basis from the price. On a depreciated aircraft, most or all of that gain is ordinary income under Section 1245.

Are lease payments in a sale-leaseback tax deductible?

Rent for property used in your business is generally deductible if the lease is a true lease. IRS Publication 334 says you cannot deduct rent if you have or will receive equity in or title to the property, which is why the purchase option matters.

What makes the IRS treat a sale-leaseback as a loan?

The IRS looks at substance over form. Rev. Proc. 2001-28 sets advance ruling guidelines that include a lessor at-risk investment of at least 20 percent, an expected residual of at least 20 percent of cost and no lessee purchase right below fair market value. A nominal buyout points toward financing.

Can I deduct a loss if I sell my aircraft for less than its tax basis?

A loss on business property is generally a Section 1231 loss, and a net Section 1231 loss is ordinary. Losses on sales to related persons, such as a company you control, are not deductible under Section 267.

Does the business use test still matter after a sale-leaseback?

Yes. A business aircraft is listed property. IRS Publication 946 says a lessee of listed property must add an inclusion amount to income in the first year qualified business use is 50% or less.

Sources

This guide is educational and is not tax, legal or investment advice. See our editorial standards and disclosures. Spot an error? Tell us.